Worship in Edinburgh, Scotland

July 24, 2011 - Edinburgh, United Kingdom

I went to the Service of Holy Communion at St. Andrew and St. George Parish Church here in Edinburgh, just off St. Andrew Square. It is a beautiful building (I've posted a picture of it earlier). Though small by Scotland standards, the building is significantly larger than most U.S. church buildings. As I walked in, I saw there were about a dozen chairs gathered in a circle around the altar in the chancel, half of them occupied. It looked like they were having a meeting, so I hung back in the tiny foyer area, waiting for the meeting to break up so people could gather for worship. I soon realized no one was talking up there--apparently there was no meeting; this was worship. So I went up and prepared to sit down. Though not in obvious prayer, no one looked up or said a word. It was rather uncomfortable, even for this church geek.

I noticed that they all had bulletins, so I asked someone--startling him, apparently, by speaking to him. He mumbled something, and pointed back out in the little foyer. I went back and found a small stack of bulletins, fairly well hidden on a table with several other flyers of sorts.

Returning to the circle of silence, I took an empty chair on the opposite side (the first 6 people had taken the closest 6 chairs, causing me to have to walk around behind them). From this vantage point I could see a few other people coming into the foyer area (unseen by the "members," who, in taking the premium seats, had their backs to the door). These visitors saw our "meeting," apparently assuming the same thing I did when I entered, so they turned around and left. I was actually embarrassed.

As I was trying to figure out what to do, recognizing I was a guest in their house, I saw a couple come into the foyer, look quizzically up front, and begin talking together--pointing toward us. I caught the woman's eye, and waved them in. They smiled, and came up front--without bulletins. Now knowing where they were, I left my chair and went out into the foyer to get them some.

As I passed them in the aisle, they thanked me for welcoming them into my church. I just smiled and said, "You're welcome." I think my accent threw them off a bit, but they at least were inside. While I was back there, someone else came in, so I handed her a bulletin. Apparently, I'm now the host.

I returned to my seat, noticing that there were now only two chairs left. And sure enough, three people came in the door. What's the practice in this place when there are more people than chairs? Do they move out into the regular worship area? Do they bring chairs up and start a second row? I waited to see what the members would do--though not really expecting anything. And I wasn't disappointed. Finally, in frustration, I got up and grabbed a chair from the nave, bringing it up into the chancel area around the altar. The others scooted chairs around until there was room in the holy circle. Some of the other visitors (the ones who thanked me for welcoming them into my church), did the same when others came in. This process was repeated until there was a full complement of 20 people. Still, the members, though watching all this, hadn't moved or spoken. The visitors were acting as hosts for one another.

The pastor came in through a back door and looked surprised at the "crowd." Come to find out, he was a guest preacher, as the regular pastor was on vacation. He was welcoming, gracious, informal ("call me Tom"), and made sure we all knew that the communion table was open to everyone.

The service was wonderful, though only about twenty minutes total (no singing). The sermon alone was worth coming for. And communion was, in fact, for everyone who had gathered. Once the service was underway, I, with bulletin in hand, was fully able to participate. The only thing that seemed unusual to me during worship was that eye contact during the sharing of the peace is apparently prohibited. Either that, or everyone was noticing some unusual pattern in the carpet they hadn't paid attention to before. Or perhaps that is simply Scottish cultural procedure. I'm open.

Afterward, I spoke with a couple of people who were slow to leave (most members bolted for the door as if the building were on fire--or maybe it was just their waiting breakfast that was burning). These dawdlers were somewhat interested in where I was from and why I was there. The pastor, who had gone to the back to try and greet the hasty retreaters, then joined us and continued to be gracious and hospitable. We spoke for a few minutes, until he had to get ready for the next service (someone had since quietly arranged chairs in a small circle down in the front of the nave).

Authentic worship is just that. It is open, it is inclusive, it is unifying when done with an awareness of its inclusive nature. It is, after all, reflective of the God we worship. But the very nature of its inclusivity cannot happen apart from those who gather for it. Corporate worship is public, therefore those on the "inside" of a particular congregation are obligated to be hospitable. It isn't extra, it isn't for the ushers and greeters, nor is it reserved for those with special gifts. It is mandated by the nature of this inclusive God. In the words of the hymn, "All are welcome, all are welcome, all are welcome in this place." It is up to us, as the insiders of a local congregation, to make sure everyone who comes in the door knows this, and experiences this.

I wonder how many people have to come to this or other churches this Sunday needing the community of believers gathered in Word and sacrament, and were turned away by the "members'" unawareness of their role as acting hosts? Hospitality isn't added on or plugged in, it is at the heart of worship.

Tags: ,


paul neukirch:
July 24, 2011
Isn't it wonderful how God provides those seemingly serendititous experiences that help us to resolve the very questions we are trying to address in our life. Here you are in Edinburgh working on fine-tuning the application of your doctoral dissertation on more fully integrating the local congregation into the life of the community it serves and you have just been given a good three pages of text. This is wonderful writing. Unfortunately it discloses that what is symptomatic of the contemporary Church in this country has a greater universality - the Church in so many placs has become a clubhouse for members only.
One would think that with all the cathedral ruins that dot the European countryside that the falacy of the Church being the building we go to on Sunday morning would be so obvious. Apparently not. Having just recently heard Pastor Eric preach on the 3rd Commandment and re-visited Walt Wangerin's exposition on the 4th Commandment and just this week at least skimmend the articles about the importance of Sabbath rest in the most recent issue of The Lutheran, be open to God's restorative power as you experience the remainder of you Sabbath day.
I am truly appreciative of this vehicle for sharing your experiences with family and friends.
July 24, 2011
Paul's right....this plays perfectly into your "application book". I think God put you there for a reason. And those people who you "touched' today, had a much greater experience in the body of Christ. They saw God at work.
h. leverkuhn:
July 25, 2011
Omigosh, Rob, if you can get us all to act like you did in that service today, we could really become the Body of Christ here. Bravo for you. Love your postings.
J.V. Xavier:
July 25, 2011
Great post! I was pulpit supply in Balaton, MN yesterday. (Long Story) I explained that at such times it is with great joy that I, as the visitor, welcome them to worship at their church.
July 25, 2011
It's a great story, and all too true in so many churches. While the behavior you described seems rather extreme, it is something that happens in one form or another in many churches; and is something for all of us to think about and take back to our congragations. Let's hope that, moving forward, none of us would allow our home churches to be seen as exclusive as you experienced in Edinburgh.
Fuzzy Travel · Next »
Create blog · Login